In short. The question is almost never “is this content true?” in the abstract, but “what can the available technical material establish?”. The answer depends above all on what was preserved.
The screenshot: fragile by nature
A screenshot is an image. It contains neither the real sender, nor the server timestamp, nor the metadata of the original message, and it can be altered in seconds. It is not worthless, but it is easy to challenge. The useful reflex: keep the message itself, on the phone or in the account where it is stored, and do not delete the conversation.
Email: many clues, provided you have the original
An email carries technical headers: servers it passed through, timestamps, results of authentication checks (SPF, DKIM, DMARC). A spoofed or edited message often leaves inconsistencies there. A printout or a simple forward loses part of that information; the original, in the original mailbox or exported as an .eml or .msg file, says far more.
Documents, photos, recordings
Word files, PDFs and photos carry metadata: software used, creation and modification dates, the camera that took the picture. It can be altered, but rarely in a fully consistent way. A PDF sometimes keeps its successive versions, which can show what changed after a signature.
Deepfakes: caution both ways
Cloned voices and doctored videos have become available to everyone. No tool detects them with certainty, and authentic content can also be wrongly accused of being a deepfake. A serious analysis cross-checks several indicators and states clearly what is established, what is probable and what remains undetermined.
What to do right now
- Keep the original — message, file or device — without altering it.
- Note where the content came from, and when and how you received it.
- Avoid forwarding the file to many people.
- Have the item examined before producing it in proceedings.
Our Content authenticity page describes what we examine and the limits of the analysis.
By Jean-Pierre Heymans, entered in the Belgian national register of judicial experts (EXP2018610).